Iter-4360dd15-0071-minimal-audit-rules

4360dd15 knowledge method

修改:20260424201843000

第 71 轮:摘要抽取字段、同义词映射与最小判定规则(批量版)

本轮把两篇 Tier A 试验(PMID 33977284、PMID 29408453)的人工审计经验压缩成可批量应用的最小规则集。

建议抽取字段


1. PMID
2. 题名
3. 研究类型(RCT / phase / pilot / feasibility)
4. 年龄判据(age cutoff / older adults / older human cohort)
5. 干预与对照
6. 主要终点(primary outcome / primary endpoint / main endpoint)
7. 终点域(survival / morbidity / infection / biomarker / function / safety)
8. 分类标签(longevity / proxy / feasibility)
9. 证据来源(abstract / PMC / Europe PMC)

同义词映射(最小集合)


- 年龄判据:
- ''older adults''
- ''aged at least''
- ''older human cohort''
- ''generally healthy older adults''
- ''elderly''
- longevity 词:
- ''lifespan'' / ''life extension'' / ''survival'' / ''mortality'' / ''all-cause mortality'' / ''disease-free survival'' / ''event-free survival'' / ''time to death''
- proxy 词:
- ''infection incidence'' / ''RTIs'' / ''respiratory illness'' / ''immune function'' / ''IFN-induced antiviral gene expression''
- ''cognitive'' / ''physical performance'' / ''handgrip strength'' / ''timed walks'' / ''cytokines'' / ''blood cell subsets'' / ''biomarker''
- feasibility 词:
- ''feasibility'' / ''safety'' / ''tolerability'' / ''pilot'' / ''proof-of-concept'' / ''establish the feasibility''

最小判定规则


- 若标题/摘要明确出现 feasibility/safety/tolerability/pilot/proof-of-concept,则优先判为 feasibility/safety pilot
- 否则若主要终点明确是 survival / mortality / lifespan / disease-free survival / event-free survival / time to death,则判为 longevity endpoint
- 否则若主要终点是感染负担、免疫、生理功能、认知、炎症、代谢或其他生物标志物,则判为 aging-proxy evidence
- 若只出现年龄人群但终点是 safety/feasibility,则不要把它提升为抗衰老疗效证据。

规则优先级


''feasibility/safety pilot'' > ''longevity endpoint'' > ''aging-proxy evidence''

当前批量抽取的两条已知锚点


- PMID 33977284:older adults + RTI incidence + IFN-induced antiviral gene expression ⇒ aging-proxy evidence
- PMID 29408453:older human cohort + feasibility and safety + cognition/physical/immune monitoring ⇒ feasibility/safety pilot

可复现实现提示


- 先按 PMID 拉 PMC/abstract。
- 再用上述同义词表做字符级/正则级匹配。
- 对 "RTIs" 这类缩写要显式加入缩写表,否则会漏判。

工具化尝试记录


- 本轮尝试封装自定义工具时,define_tool 的参数签名在当前环境中表现不稳定,先保留规则文本,下一轮优先做一个最小可运行的抽取脚本,再决定是否重新封装。